TOP RATED BURGERS
Burgers rated 8 out of 10 or higher
Updated September 7, 2019
Click on the name of the burger for a photo.
Disclaimer: Ratings are entirely based on W. Bonnell's opinion. The criteria include freshness, taste and texture of the meat, taste of the cheese, bun quality, special sauce, and bun to burger ratio. Ratings are subject to change based on subsequent tastings.
Click on the name of the burger for a photo.
Disclaimer: Ratings are entirely based on W. Bonnell's opinion. The criteria include freshness, taste and texture of the meat, taste of the cheese, bun quality, special sauce, and bun to burger ratio. Ratings are subject to change based on subsequent tastings.
10s
CHERRY CRICKET BURGER - Denver CO 7/18
FIVE GUYS CHEESEBURGER - National 7/18
HOPDODDY BURGER BAR CLASSIC - Denver CO 5/19
HOUSTON'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/10
MATCH BURGER LOBSTER "THE MATCH BURGER" - Westport CT 4/19
RAIL HOUSE "RAIL HOUSE BURGER" - Pekin IL 10/15
RED ROBIN BANZAI BURGER - National 8/15
RED ROBIN GOURMET CHEESEBURGER - National 12/17
RED ROBIN WHISKEY RIVER BBQ BURGER - National 6/19
(NEW) SNARFBURGER DOUBLE 9/19
SUPER DUPER BURGERS MINI CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 6/18
THURMAN CAFE BIG TC - Columbus OH 9/11
9s
APOLLO RESTAURANT CLASSIC - Victorville CA 2/17
BENT FORK CLASSIC - Aurora CO 3/07
BIG AL'S 60/40 BURGER - Fort Collins CO 7/15
BLUE WATER GRILL CHILI CRUSTED BURGER - Grand Rapids MI 10/15
BOB'S BIG BOY CLASSIC - Burbank CA 2/18
BONNELL'S FINE TEXAS CUISINE BONNELL'S BURGER - Fort Worth TX 10/18
BURGATORY STANDARD DELUXE - Pittsburgh PA 5/17
CASSELL'S CHEESEBURGER - Los Angeles CA 2/19
CITY GRILLE STEAKBURGER - Denver CO 7/03
COCO'S SOURDOUGH CHEESEBURGER - Southwest 1/10
DEL TACO DOUBLE DEL - West 9/16
EPIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Chicago 9/18
EUREKA! AMERICAN CHEESEBURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/19
FATBURGER - West 2/18
FREDDY'S DOUBLE STEAKBURGER - National 10/17
FREDDY'S STEAKBURGER CALIFORNIA STYLE - National 2/18
GILLEY'S PM LUNCH CHEESEBURGER - Portsmouth NH 10/11
(NEW) GOOD STUFF EATERY FARMHOUSE CHEESE - Washington DC 5/19
GOTT'S ROADSIDE CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 4/17
GRANDPA'S BURGER HAVEN DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER - Denver CO 4/13
GREEN LINE GRILL DELUXE - Colorado Springs CO 11/17
GREEN LINE GRILL ORIGINAL ONION FRIED BURGER - Colorado Springs CO 4/18
HILLSTONE CHEESEBURGER - Denver 1/17
IN-N-OUT DOUBLE DOUBLE - West and Texas 2/16
JANE JANE'S BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/17
JG MELON'S CHEESEBURGER - New York City NY 7/12
JOHNNIE'S HAMBURGERS ONION BURGER 10/17
JOHNNY ROCKETS #12 - National and International 7/14
JOHNNY ROCKETS ROUTE 66 - National and International 7/11
JUICY BURGERS & DOGS CHEDDAR CHAR BURGER - Centennial CO 4/16
KELLER'S #5 - Dallas TX 4/07
KINCAID'S CHEESEBURGER - Fort Worth TX 4/07
KRAZY JIM'S BLIMPYBURGER - Ann Arbor MI 9/10
LARKBURGER - CO, KS 6/18
LITTLE BIG BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 10/12
MESA BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/19
MOOYAH BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - International 8/15
RED ROBIN TAVERN DOUBLE - National 3/19
SESEME BURGERS "DOWN SOUTH" - Charleston SC 7/12
SHAKE SHACK - National 5/19
SOLLY'S GRILLE SUPER CHEESEBURGER - Milwaukee WI 9/08
STANICH'S CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 8/17
STEAK 'N SHAKE WISCONSIN BUTTERY STEAKBURGER - National 6/16
TAG BURGER BAR OLD SCHOOL - Denver CO 9/18
8s
APPLE PAN HICKORY BURGER - Los Angeles CA 3/13
APPLE PAN STEAKBURGER - Los Angeles CA 3/13
BOB'S ATOMIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Golden CO 10/12
(NEW)BROTHERS RESTAURANT BROTHERS BURGER - Santa Ynez CA 2/19
BURGER ROYAL "ROYAL AVEC FROMAGE" - Montreal Canada 5/18
(NEW) BUBBA'S 33 CLASSIC CHEESEBURGER - Colorado Springs CO 3/19
BULLY RANCH CHEESEBURGER - Vail CO 5/15
BURGER STOP CHEESEBURGER - Anchorage AK 5/12
CASTLE CAFE ROCK BURGER - Castle Rock CO 3/15
CHEDDAR'S CHEESEBURGER 3/17
CHILI'S OLDTIMER - National 5/16
CHUBBIES HAMBURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/18
COOK OUT CHEESEBURGER COOK OUT STYLE - Richmond KY 10/17
DYER'S BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Memphis TN 10/17
DRIFTER'S CHEESEBURGER - Colorado Springs CO 6/19
ELEVATION BURGER CHEESEBURGER - East 9/14
(NEW) EUREKA! COWBOY BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/19
(NEW) FATBELLY BURGERS "THE STANDARD" - Carbondale CO 3/19
HUDSON'S HAMBURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Coeur d'Alene ID 9/12
IRON HORSE GRILL IRON HORSE BURGER - Jackson MS 8/15
JIFFY BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Smith Center KS 10/17
JM CURLEY CHEESEBURGER - Boston MA 9/14
JOHNNY ROCKETS ROCKET SINGLE - National 1/14
KROLL'S DINER FRISCO BURGER MELT - Bismarck ND 7/15
LONE STAR STEAK BURGER - National 3/13
MAHALOHA BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Waikiki HI 8/16
MARTY'S CHEESEBURGER - West Los Angeles CA 8/11
MATT'S BAR JUCY LUCY - Minneapolis MN 10/14
MCDONALD'S BIG MAC - National 6/19
MCMENAMINS CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 8/17
MEATHEADS "THE MEATHEAD" - IL 6/16
MELVIN'S CHEESEBURGER - Elizabethtown NC 8/10
MR. BARTLEY'S BURGER COTTAGE "TOM BRADY" - Cambridge MA 10/11
MUSTARD'S LAST STAND CHARBURGER - Denver CO 8/15
PENELOPE'S CHEESEBURGER - Estes Park CO 8/18
RED ROBIN ALL-AMERICAN PATTY MELT - National 7/10
RED ROBIN SAUTEED 'SHROOM BURGER 12/18
ROYAL "THE HEIR" - Denver CO 8/16
ROBERT'S GRILL CHEESEBURGER - El Reno OK 10/10
SKIRTED HEIFER CLASSIC - Colorado Springs CO 4/17
SID'S DINER CHEESEBURGER - El Reno OK 10/10
SMASHBURGER BBQ, BACON & CHEDDAR 8/19
SMASHBURGER CLASSIC - National 5/19
SMASHBURGER TRUFFLE MUSHROOM SWISS - National 9/17
STEUBEN'S CHEESEBURGER - Arvada CO 3/18
STEWZ MAUI BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Maui HI 8/16
TED'S MONTANA GRILL CHEESEBURGER - National 6/16
TED'S MONTANA GRILL SWISS & MUSHROOM - National 6/08
THE MELT ORIGINAL CHEDDAR BURGER - CA & TX 12/16
THE MELT 'SHROOM & SWISS BURGER - CA & TX 3/16
UMAMI BURGER THE ORIGINAL - Los Angeles CA 2/14
(NEW) WAHLBURGERS OUR BURGER - Trumbull CT 4/19
WAYBACK BURGERS CLASSIC - National 4/19
WEE SHACK SHACK BURGER - Morro Bay CA 1/18
WENDY'S DAVE'S SINGLE - National 8/19
WHITE MANNA CHEESEBURGER - Hackensack NJ 5/18
10s
CHERRY CRICKET BURGER - Denver CO 7/18
FIVE GUYS CHEESEBURGER - National 7/18
HOPDODDY BURGER BAR CLASSIC - Denver CO 5/19
HOUSTON'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/10
MATCH BURGER LOBSTER "THE MATCH BURGER" - Westport CT 4/19
RAIL HOUSE "RAIL HOUSE BURGER" - Pekin IL 10/15
RED ROBIN BANZAI BURGER - National 8/15
RED ROBIN GOURMET CHEESEBURGER - National 12/17
RED ROBIN WHISKEY RIVER BBQ BURGER - National 6/19
(NEW) SNARFBURGER DOUBLE 9/19
SUPER DUPER BURGERS MINI CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 6/18
THURMAN CAFE BIG TC - Columbus OH 9/11
9s
APOLLO RESTAURANT CLASSIC - Victorville CA 2/17
BENT FORK CLASSIC - Aurora CO 3/07
BIG AL'S 60/40 BURGER - Fort Collins CO 7/15
BLUE WATER GRILL CHILI CRUSTED BURGER - Grand Rapids MI 10/15
BOB'S BIG BOY CLASSIC - Burbank CA 2/18
BONNELL'S FINE TEXAS CUISINE BONNELL'S BURGER - Fort Worth TX 10/18
BURGATORY STANDARD DELUXE - Pittsburgh PA 5/17
CASSELL'S CHEESEBURGER - Los Angeles CA 2/19
CITY GRILLE STEAKBURGER - Denver CO 7/03
COCO'S SOURDOUGH CHEESEBURGER - Southwest 1/10
DEL TACO DOUBLE DEL - West 9/16
EPIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Chicago 9/18
EUREKA! AMERICAN CHEESEBURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/19
FATBURGER - West 2/18
FREDDY'S DOUBLE STEAKBURGER - National 10/17
FREDDY'S STEAKBURGER CALIFORNIA STYLE - National 2/18
GILLEY'S PM LUNCH CHEESEBURGER - Portsmouth NH 10/11
(NEW) GOOD STUFF EATERY FARMHOUSE CHEESE - Washington DC 5/19
GOTT'S ROADSIDE CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 4/17
GRANDPA'S BURGER HAVEN DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER - Denver CO 4/13
GREEN LINE GRILL DELUXE - Colorado Springs CO 11/17
GREEN LINE GRILL ORIGINAL ONION FRIED BURGER - Colorado Springs CO 4/18
HILLSTONE CHEESEBURGER - Denver 1/17
IN-N-OUT DOUBLE DOUBLE - West and Texas 2/16
JANE JANE'S BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/17
JG MELON'S CHEESEBURGER - New York City NY 7/12
JOHNNIE'S HAMBURGERS ONION BURGER 10/17
JOHNNY ROCKETS #12 - National and International 7/14
JOHNNY ROCKETS ROUTE 66 - National and International 7/11
JUICY BURGERS & DOGS CHEDDAR CHAR BURGER - Centennial CO 4/16
KELLER'S #5 - Dallas TX 4/07
KINCAID'S CHEESEBURGER - Fort Worth TX 4/07
KRAZY JIM'S BLIMPYBURGER - Ann Arbor MI 9/10
LARKBURGER - CO, KS 6/18
LITTLE BIG BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 10/12
MESA BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/19
MOOYAH BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - International 8/15
RED ROBIN TAVERN DOUBLE - National 3/19
SESEME BURGERS "DOWN SOUTH" - Charleston SC 7/12
SHAKE SHACK - National 5/19
SOLLY'S GRILLE SUPER CHEESEBURGER - Milwaukee WI 9/08
STANICH'S CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 8/17
STEAK 'N SHAKE WISCONSIN BUTTERY STEAKBURGER - National 6/16
TAG BURGER BAR OLD SCHOOL - Denver CO 9/18
8s
APPLE PAN HICKORY BURGER - Los Angeles CA 3/13
APPLE PAN STEAKBURGER - Los Angeles CA 3/13
BOB'S ATOMIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Golden CO 10/12
(NEW)BROTHERS RESTAURANT BROTHERS BURGER - Santa Ynez CA 2/19
BURGER ROYAL "ROYAL AVEC FROMAGE" - Montreal Canada 5/18
(NEW) BUBBA'S 33 CLASSIC CHEESEBURGER - Colorado Springs CO 3/19
BULLY RANCH CHEESEBURGER - Vail CO 5/15
BURGER STOP CHEESEBURGER - Anchorage AK 5/12
CASTLE CAFE ROCK BURGER - Castle Rock CO 3/15
CHEDDAR'S CHEESEBURGER 3/17
CHILI'S OLDTIMER - National 5/16
CHUBBIES HAMBURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/18
COOK OUT CHEESEBURGER COOK OUT STYLE - Richmond KY 10/17
DYER'S BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Memphis TN 10/17
DRIFTER'S CHEESEBURGER - Colorado Springs CO 6/19
ELEVATION BURGER CHEESEBURGER - East 9/14
(NEW) EUREKA! COWBOY BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 2/19
(NEW) FATBELLY BURGERS "THE STANDARD" - Carbondale CO 3/19
HUDSON'S HAMBURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Coeur d'Alene ID 9/12
IRON HORSE GRILL IRON HORSE BURGER - Jackson MS 8/15
JIFFY BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Smith Center KS 10/17
JM CURLEY CHEESEBURGER - Boston MA 9/14
JOHNNY ROCKETS ROCKET SINGLE - National 1/14
KROLL'S DINER FRISCO BURGER MELT - Bismarck ND 7/15
LONE STAR STEAK BURGER - National 3/13
MAHALOHA BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Waikiki HI 8/16
MARTY'S CHEESEBURGER - West Los Angeles CA 8/11
MATT'S BAR JUCY LUCY - Minneapolis MN 10/14
MCDONALD'S BIG MAC - National 6/19
MCMENAMINS CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 8/17
MEATHEADS "THE MEATHEAD" - IL 6/16
MELVIN'S CHEESEBURGER - Elizabethtown NC 8/10
MR. BARTLEY'S BURGER COTTAGE "TOM BRADY" - Cambridge MA 10/11
MUSTARD'S LAST STAND CHARBURGER - Denver CO 8/15
PENELOPE'S CHEESEBURGER - Estes Park CO 8/18
RED ROBIN ALL-AMERICAN PATTY MELT - National 7/10
RED ROBIN SAUTEED 'SHROOM BURGER 12/18
ROYAL "THE HEIR" - Denver CO 8/16
ROBERT'S GRILL CHEESEBURGER - El Reno OK 10/10
SKIRTED HEIFER CLASSIC - Colorado Springs CO 4/17
SID'S DINER CHEESEBURGER - El Reno OK 10/10
SMASHBURGER BBQ, BACON & CHEDDAR 8/19
SMASHBURGER CLASSIC - National 5/19
SMASHBURGER TRUFFLE MUSHROOM SWISS - National 9/17
STEUBEN'S CHEESEBURGER - Arvada CO 3/18
STEWZ MAUI BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - Maui HI 8/16
TED'S MONTANA GRILL CHEESEBURGER - National 6/16
TED'S MONTANA GRILL SWISS & MUSHROOM - National 6/08
THE MELT ORIGINAL CHEDDAR BURGER - CA & TX 12/16
THE MELT 'SHROOM & SWISS BURGER - CA & TX 3/16
UMAMI BURGER THE ORIGINAL - Los Angeles CA 2/14
(NEW) WAHLBURGERS OUR BURGER - Trumbull CT 4/19
WAYBACK BURGERS CLASSIC - National 4/19
WEE SHACK SHACK BURGER - Morro Bay CA 1/18
WENDY'S DAVE'S SINGLE - National 8/19
WHITE MANNA CHEESEBURGER - Hackensack NJ 5/18
