TOP RATED BURGERS
Burgers rated 9 or 10
Updated June 7, 2025
Click on the name of the burger for a photo.
Disclaimer: Ratings are entirely based on W. Bonnell's opinion. The criteria include freshness, taste and texture of the meat, taste of the cheese, bun quality, special sauce, and bun to burger ratio. Ratings are subject to change based on subsequent tastings.
Click on the name of the burger for a photo.
Disclaimer: Ratings are entirely based on W. Bonnell's opinion. The criteria include freshness, taste and texture of the meat, taste of the cheese, bun quality, special sauce, and bun to burger ratio. Ratings are subject to change based on subsequent tastings.
10s
CHERRY CRICKET BURGER - Denver CO 9/23
(NEW) CULVER'S SOURDOUGH MELT - Lakewood CO 9/24
HOPDODDY BURGER BAR CLASSIC - Denver CO 10/20
HOUSTON'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/10
IN-N-OUT DOUBLE DOUBLE - West and Texas 10/24
MATCH BURGER LOBSTER "THE MATCH BURGER" - Westport CT 4/19
RAIL HOUSE "RAIL HOUSE BURGER" - Pekin IL 10/15
RED ROBIN WHISKEY RIVER BBQ BURGER - National 12/22
SNARFBURGER DOUBLE - Denver CO 9/19
SUPER DUPER BURGERS MINI CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 6/18
THURMAN CAFE BIG TC - Columbus OH 9/11
9s
APOLLO RESTAURANT CLASSIC - Victorville CA 2/17
BENT FORK CLASSIC - Aurora CO 3/07
BIG AL'S 60/40 BURGER - Fort Collins CO 7/15
BLUE WATER GRILL CHILI CRUSTED BURGER - Grand Rapids MI 10/15
BONNELL'S FINE TEXAS CUISINE BONNELL'S BURGER - Fort Worth TX 10/18
BURGATORY STANDARD DELUXE - Pittsburgh PA 5/17
CASSELL'S CHEESEBURGER - Los Angeles CA 2/19
CHEDDAR'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/24
CHEESECAKE FACTORY AMERICANA CHEESEBURGER 3/20
CITY GRILLE STEAKBURGER - Denver CO 7/03
COCO'S SOURDOUGH CHEESEBURGER - Southwest 1/10
(CLOSED) DUTCHFIX GOUDA BURGER - Pella IA 10/21
EPIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Chicago 9/18
FATBURGER - West 2/18
NEW) FINNEY'S CRAFTHOUSE "FINNEY BURGER" - San Luis Obispo 9 2/24
FIVE GUYS CHEESEBURGER - National 12/23
FREDDY'S ORIGINAL DOUBLE WITH CHEESE - National 11/22
FREDDY'S STEAKBURGER CALIFORNIA STYLE - National 12/24
FRESH BURGER STOP FRESH BURGER - Estes Park CO 8/24
GILLEY'S PM LUNCH CHEESEBURGER - Portsmouth NH 10/11
GOOD STUFF EATERY FARMHOUSE CHEESE - Washington DC 5/19
GOTT'S ROADSIDE CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 4/17
GRANDPA'S BURGER HAVEN DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER - Denver CO 4/13
GREEN LINE GRILL DELUXE - Colorado Springs CO 11/17
GREEN LINE GRILL ORIGINAL ONION FRIED BURGER - Colorado Springs CO 4/18
HILLSTONE CHEESEBURGER - Denver 1/17
JANE JANE'S BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/17
JG MELON'S CHEESEBURGER - New York City NY 7/12
JOHNNIE'S HAMBURGERS ONION BURGER - El Reno OK 10/17
(CLOSED IN COLORADO) JOHNNY ROCKETS #12 - National and International 7/14
(CLOSED IN COLORADO) JOHNNY ROCKETS ROUTE 66 - National and International 7/11
KELLER'S #5 - Dallas TX 4/07
KINCAID'S CHEESEBURGER - Fort Worth TX 4/07
KRAZY JIM'S BLIMPYBURGER - Ann Arbor MI 9/10
LARKBURGER - CO 6/18
LITTLE BIG BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 10/12
MOOYAH BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - International 8/15
RED ROBIN COWBOY RANCH TAVERN DOUBLE 8/20
RED ROBIN GOURMET CHEESEBURGER - National 12/24
RED ROBIN RED'S DOUBLE TAVERN BURGER 6/25
SESEME BURGERS "DOWN SOUTH" - Charleston SC 7/12
(NEW) SB BIERGARTEN "SMATTY" - Santa Barbara CA 2/24
SHAKE SHACK - National 2/21
SOLLY'S GRILLE SUPER CHEESEBURGER - Milwaukee WI 9/08
(NEW) THIRD WINDOW "THE ORIGINAL SMASHED BURGER" - Santa Barbara CA 9 2/24
10s
CHERRY CRICKET BURGER - Denver CO 9/23
(NEW) CULVER'S SOURDOUGH MELT - Lakewood CO 9/24
HOPDODDY BURGER BAR CLASSIC - Denver CO 10/20
HOUSTON'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/10
IN-N-OUT DOUBLE DOUBLE - West and Texas 10/24
MATCH BURGER LOBSTER "THE MATCH BURGER" - Westport CT 4/19
RAIL HOUSE "RAIL HOUSE BURGER" - Pekin IL 10/15
RED ROBIN WHISKEY RIVER BBQ BURGER - National 12/22
SNARFBURGER DOUBLE - Denver CO 9/19
SUPER DUPER BURGERS MINI CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 6/18
THURMAN CAFE BIG TC - Columbus OH 9/11
9s
APOLLO RESTAURANT CLASSIC - Victorville CA 2/17
BENT FORK CLASSIC - Aurora CO 3/07
BIG AL'S 60/40 BURGER - Fort Collins CO 7/15
BLUE WATER GRILL CHILI CRUSTED BURGER - Grand Rapids MI 10/15
BONNELL'S FINE TEXAS CUISINE BONNELL'S BURGER - Fort Worth TX 10/18
BURGATORY STANDARD DELUXE - Pittsburgh PA 5/17
CASSELL'S CHEESEBURGER - Los Angeles CA 2/19
CHEDDAR'S CHEESEBURGER - National 1/24
CHEESECAKE FACTORY AMERICANA CHEESEBURGER 3/20
CITY GRILLE STEAKBURGER - Denver CO 7/03
COCO'S SOURDOUGH CHEESEBURGER - Southwest 1/10
(CLOSED) DUTCHFIX GOUDA BURGER - Pella IA 10/21
EPIC BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Chicago 9/18
FATBURGER - West 2/18
NEW) FINNEY'S CRAFTHOUSE "FINNEY BURGER" - San Luis Obispo 9 2/24
FIVE GUYS CHEESEBURGER - National 12/23
FREDDY'S ORIGINAL DOUBLE WITH CHEESE - National 11/22
FREDDY'S STEAKBURGER CALIFORNIA STYLE - National 12/24
FRESH BURGER STOP FRESH BURGER - Estes Park CO 8/24
GILLEY'S PM LUNCH CHEESEBURGER - Portsmouth NH 10/11
GOOD STUFF EATERY FARMHOUSE CHEESE - Washington DC 5/19
GOTT'S ROADSIDE CHEESEBURGER - San Francisco CA 4/17
GRANDPA'S BURGER HAVEN DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER - Denver CO 4/13
GREEN LINE GRILL DELUXE - Colorado Springs CO 11/17
GREEN LINE GRILL ORIGINAL ONION FRIED BURGER - Colorado Springs CO 4/18
HILLSTONE CHEESEBURGER - Denver 1/17
JANE JANE'S BURGER - Santa Barbara CA 1/17
JG MELON'S CHEESEBURGER - New York City NY 7/12
JOHNNIE'S HAMBURGERS ONION BURGER - El Reno OK 10/17
(CLOSED IN COLORADO) JOHNNY ROCKETS #12 - National and International 7/14
(CLOSED IN COLORADO) JOHNNY ROCKETS ROUTE 66 - National and International 7/11
KELLER'S #5 - Dallas TX 4/07
KINCAID'S CHEESEBURGER - Fort Worth TX 4/07
KRAZY JIM'S BLIMPYBURGER - Ann Arbor MI 9/10
LARKBURGER - CO 6/18
LITTLE BIG BURGER CHEESEBURGER - Portland OR 10/12
MOOYAH BURGERS CHEESEBURGER - International 8/15
RED ROBIN COWBOY RANCH TAVERN DOUBLE 8/20
RED ROBIN GOURMET CHEESEBURGER - National 12/24
RED ROBIN RED'S DOUBLE TAVERN BURGER 6/25
SESEME BURGERS "DOWN SOUTH" - Charleston SC 7/12
(NEW) SB BIERGARTEN "SMATTY" - Santa Barbara CA 2/24
SHAKE SHACK - National 2/21
SOLLY'S GRILLE SUPER CHEESEBURGER - Milwaukee WI 9/08
(NEW) THIRD WINDOW "THE ORIGINAL SMASHED BURGER" - Santa Barbara CA 9 2/24
